Reality Filter
Tue, Apr. 15th, 2008 16:39Under the cuts are a pair of essay/rants I wrote in another forum, slightly cleaned up to be less context-specific, on the topic of Being a Reader. I expect the forum admin to delete the thread shortly, and wanted to save these for future reference: I might someday discover I'm off the mark, here.
I started off the first essay by quoting the prompter's arc-wide complaint, and then quoted (with citations to episode and chapter) two specific examples that directly countered his claim. I could've posted more, but two seems like a solid argument where three (or more) seems like haranguing.
***
***
The person who prompted the first rant replied with something rather unsettling, and I had to call him on it. The full body of work currently contains fifty-four completed short stories, some of them novella length, a couple possibly novel-length. I'm a fairly fast reader, and I cannot quite read them all in one lazy Sunday. The prompter started the conversation discussing "most of the main story", which later turns out to be inaccurate -- he's only read a little under two-thirds of it, and is decrying supposedly widespread flaws across the entire work.
***
I started off the first essay by quoting the prompter's arc-wide complaint, and then quoted (with citations to episode and chapter) two specific examples that directly countered his claim. I could've posted more, but two seems like a solid argument where three (or more) seems like haranguing.
***
***
The person who prompted the first rant replied with something rather unsettling, and I had to call him on it. The full body of work currently contains fifty-four completed short stories, some of them novella length, a couple possibly novel-length. I'm a fairly fast reader, and I cannot quite read them all in one lazy Sunday. The prompter started the conversation discussing "most of the main story", which later turns out to be inaccurate -- he's only read a little under two-thirds of it, and is decrying supposedly widespread flaws across the entire work.
***
( Well, not )